Girls Like Toys Too!!

We are a vintage/retro girls toy store located in Gettysburg, PA. Since most vintage toy stores focus on the boy lines, we decided it was time for us girls to have our own store! We carry girl toys from the 70s, 80s, 90s, early 2000s, and more!

Our Gettysburg Store

OPENING June 15th 2026: We are located at: ~ The Gettysburg Outlets ~ 1863 Gettysburg Village Dr ~ Suite 930 ~ Gettysburg ~ PA ~ 17325

Hours

  • Sunday- 10:00 am to 6:00 pm
  • Monday – Closed
  • Tuesday – Saturday – 10:00 am to 7:00 pm

NEWS & UPDATES!

Updates: Our new Gettysburg store located at the Gettysburg Outlets will be opening June 15th! Our grand opening celebration birthday party will be June 27th! We will also be at the Maryland Toy Expo June 13th!

Shopping Online!

Check out our Ebay Store!

 

Social Media

Facebook Updates

Play Like A Girl Retro Toys

7 days ago

Play Like A Girl Retro Toys
Good morning! More ponies going out later today! Just a reminder of our shipping policy as we had a lot of people asking for shipping. Our shipping policy is pinned at the top of our page here. Items must be in store for a week before we will offer shipping, so these ponies will be allowed for shipping and holds next Sunday.A schedule change this week! We will be closing at 2:30pm this Thursday (8/27/26)! Its that time of year for back to school events and I refuse to throw my freshman son to the wolves on the first day of school without at least getting a chance to see where his classes may be in a new to him school 😂Don't forget also our flash sale is open still until 8 pm EST tonight! You can still claim items if you haven't already. Join our flash sale group here: www.facebook.com/groups/1355602062141 We are open today in Gettysburg until 6 pm!Gettysburg Outlet Shoppes1863 Gettysburg Village Dr Suite 930Gettysburg, PA 17325Check out our online store!www.ebay.com/str/xmarksthespotshopJoin our Flash/Claim sale group! (Be sure to select "I Agree" after joining, otherwise it auto declines. This is how we filter spammers 🙂 )www.facebook.com/groups/1355602062141 #playlikeagirlretrotoys #plagrt #mlp #mylittlepony … See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share by Email

We Buy Toys

*Please note we do not take walk in buys!

We are looking for gently loved girl and gender neutral toys mainly from the 70s, 80s, 90s, and early 2000s. If you are interested in selling your toys, please email us at [email protected] with pictures and descriptions of your items. You can also send us pictures in Facebook or Instagram.

Our process:

1. We will review your pictures and ask any questions on the items. Please be sure to mention any issues, flaws, etc. We will let you know what we are interested in and then send you an offer.

2. Once we settle on a price we will schedule a day for you to bring in the toys.

3. We will exchange on our scheduled day. We pay in cash and will give you a signed receipt to have record of the transaction

Please note we do not take walk in buys. Please email us first to start the process. All sales are final so please be sure you are ready to let go of your toys!

Toys in high demand: Care Bears, Polly Pocket, Strawberry Shortcake, Popples, Rainbow Brite, Littlest Pet Shop, vintage Sanrio and My Little Pony.

Examples of some items we do not take: Damaged toys, recalled toys (such as Skydancers), plug in outlet toys, and used Barbies